Latest
Talent News

Johnny Gargano Details Decision to Return to WWE After Allowing Contract to Expire

Speaking on Busted Open Radio in comments covered Nov. 20–21, 2026 by Wrestling Inc., WWE SmackDown star Johnny Gargano explained how watching a WrestleMania Shawn Michaels vs. Undertaker video package during his 2021–22 free agency convinced him to return to WWE.

Read the story
Talent News · Read the story
PWSignal Talent News thumbnail reading ‘GARGANO ON / WWE RETURN / DECISION’ with gold bar and black lettering ‘RECALLS FREE-AGENT PAUSE / AFTER CONTRACT EXPIRED’ beside a gold-accented arms-crossed masked male wrestler sprite and microphone.
Illustration · PWSignal
Share this story

STAMFORD, Conn. (Nov. 21, 2026) — WWE SmackDown veteran Johnny Gargano says a classic WrestleMania video package was the tipping point that brought him back to WWE after he chose to let his previous contract expire five years ago.

Speaking on Busted Open Radio in comments transcribed by Wrestling Inc.’s Nick Miller, Gargano reflected on his nine-month stretch as a free agent between late 2021 and his August 2022 return, explaining that WWE’s emphasis on long-form storytelling proved impossible to pass up.

FREE AGENCY WINDOWLate 2021 – Aug. 2022 (9 months)
TURNING POINTMichaels vs. Undertaker WM buildup
2026 SMACKDOWN ROLEAllied with champion Sami Zayn

The WrestleMania Video That Changed His Mind

When Gargano stepped away from NXT in late 2021 as his contract ran out and his wife, WWE star Candice LeRae, was pregnant, he stayed completely off wrestling television while weighing his future. Sitting at home during that break, one archival vignette crystallized where he belonged.

“The storytelling stuff is what really gets me going,” Gargano said on Busted Open Radio. “That time period where I let my contract expire, and I wasn’t anywhere, and I was a free agent, and Candice [LeRae] was pregnant, I remember sitting at home and … I watched the build-up to Shawn [Michaels] and Undertaker with that ‘Running Up That Hill’ song from WrestleMania. … I remember sitting there thinking, ‘Oh, I’ve got to go back to WWE. That’s why I got in the business, is this. I want to do this, and that’s the place to do it.’ That’s what made my mind up there.”

From #DIY Reunion to 2026 SmackDown Resurgence

After returning on Raw in August 2022, Gargano reunited #DIY with longtime partner Tommaso Ciampa for a multi-year main-roster run. When Ciampa announced his imminent departure from WWE in January 2026, Gargano’s onscreen character spiraled into a storyline slump without his partner beside him.

  • Late 2021: Johnny Gargano allows his WWE contract to expire and steps away during Candice LeRae’s pregnancy.
  • August 2022: Gargano returns to WWE on Raw after nine months off television, eventually reforming #DIY with Tommaso Ciampa.
  • January 2026: Ciampa announces his departure from WWE, triggering a scripted onscreen slump for Gargano on SmackDown.
  • Fall 2026: Following an Undisputed WWE Championship bout against CM Punk on SmackDown, Gargano regains weekly television momentum and aligns onscreen with current champion Sami Zayn.

Storyline vs. Real-World Note: Gargano’s 2021 contract expiration, August 2022 return, and Ciampa’s January 2026 WWE exit are verified real-world career developments; Gargano’s post-Ciampa onscreen depression arc and current alliance with Sami Zayn are scripted SmackDown storylines.

Featured Wrestlers in This Story

WWE · Talent & Contract Spotlight 1 / 2
WWE · SmackDown PWSignal spotlight illustration for Johnny Gargano.

Johnny Gargano

Revealed on Busted Open Radio that watching WrestleMania storytelling during his 2021–22 free agency prompted his WWE return.

Illustration · PWSignal

Sources and Credits

Reporting sources: Wrestling Inc. (Nick Miller — Busted Open Radio transcript), Wrestling Inc. (Aug. 2022 return), Wrestling Inc. (Jan. 2026 Ciampa departure), and WWE on X (2022 return clip).

Visuals: Category-calibrated PWSignal barbed-wire banner in Talent News gold, arms-crossed masked male wrestler sprite, microphone prop graphic, and interactive spotlight slideshow created by PWSignal (Illustration · PWSignal).